What the Oscar Cocktail tastes like
Cherry brandy is a sweet cherry liqueur rather than a dry spirit, and it leads the flavour here, with grenadine adding a deeper red-berry sweetness. The apple juice gives it a soft, rounded fruitiness and the orange soda finishes it with sugar and bubbles. Gin and vodka together keep it from tasting like a soft drink, though neither is easy to pick out.
It is a sweet drink, so it suits people who like punchy fruit flavours and not those after a dry, bitter cocktail. The gin adds a faint herbal edge that stops it being cloying.
Building it so the fizz lasts and the sweetness stays in check
Fill the snifter with plenty of ice first, since a snifter is wide and warms quickly, and cold ice means less dilution. Pour in the gin, vodka, cherry brandy, grenadine and apple juice, then add the orange soda last so the bubbles survive. Give it one gentle turn with a spoon rather than a hard stir.
Use a cold, freshly opened bottle of orange soda. A flat or warm one leaves the drink syrupy, and it is the main reason this style of drink ends up tasting too sweet.
Swaps, a lighter version and making a jug
If cherry brandy is hard to find, another cherry liqueur works and will change the flavour only slightly. For a drier drink, use a sugar-free orange soda or top with soda water and a squeeze of orange. Some versions of this drink use pineapple juice instead of apple, which makes it tropical and tarter.
For a lower-strength version, use only one of the two white spirits and add a little more apple juice. For a group, mix the spirits, cherry brandy, grenadine and juice in a jug without ice, pour over ice in each glass and top each one with soda individually, so the fizz is not lost.
Questions
Is the Oscar Cocktail very strong?
Yes. Gin, vodka and cherry brandy make up most of the glass, and the juice and orange soda hide the alcohol well. Drink it slowly and keep water nearby.
What is cherry brandy?
In this drink it means a sweet cherry liqueur, not a dry brandy. It is the main source of the cherry flavour and the red colour, along with the grenadine.
Can I use pineapple juice instead of apple juice?
You can. Pineapple makes the drink fruitier and more tropical, with a bit more tartness, while apple keeps it softer and rounder. Both are common in versions of this drink, so use whichever you prefer.
