How a spiced rum colada differs from the classic
A traditional piña colada uses white rum, which stays out of the way. Spiced rum brings vanilla, cinnamon and a hint of caramel, so this colada tastes warmer and a little richer, closer to a tropical dessert than a beach cooler. Fans of the classic usually like it because the spice stops the coconut feeling one-note.
Getting the texture and sweetness right
The juice is the part to get right. Pineapple juice is the classic partner for coconut and rum, and most versions of this drink use it. Apple juice makes a gentler, less tropical drink that is worth trying if you find pineapple too sharp. Use chilled juice, since it blends colder and keeps the ice from melting into a watery mess.
Blend with plenty of crushed ice until the drink is smooth and frothy, but stop as soon as it is thick. Over-blending melts the ice and thins the drink. Other recipe pages point out that cream of coconut is a sweetened product, while coconut cream is not, so this recipe gets its sweetness mostly from the juice and the rum. If yours tastes flat, add a little sugar syrup, and if it tastes too sweet, add a squeeze of lime.
Swaps, a lighter version and serving a crowd
If you only have white rum, add a pinch of cinnamon and a drop of vanilla essence and you will get close. For a thicker, creamier drink, add extra coconut cream, and for a stronger one, add a little more rum. Frozen pineapple chunks instead of some of the ice make a thicker, fruitier colada.
For a lighter drink, halve the rum and add more juice. For a party, blend a large batch in rounds, keep it in a freezer-safe jug and give it a quick stir before pouring. An alcohol-free version works well with the same juice, coconut cream and a splash of vanilla syrup.
Questions
Can I make a Captain's Colada without a blender?
It is possible but harder. Blend the rum, juice and coconut cream with plenty of crushed ice, then pour it all into a glass. You will get a cold, creamy drink, but it will be thinner than a blended one.
What is the difference between coconut cream and cream of coconut?
Coconut cream is the thick, unsweetened top of coconut milk. Cream of coconut is sweetened and syrupy, so it makes a sweeter drink. This recipe uses coconut cream, so you may want a touch of sugar if you like it sweet.
What glass is best?
A goblet or tall hurricane glass shows off the frosty colour. Any large glass works. Chill it in the freezer first, because a cold glass keeps the colada thick for longer while you drink it.
