What the apple juice is doing
Apple juice stands in for the pineapple of a classic colada. It gives sweetness without much acid, so the strawberry and coconut taste clearer and the drink does not tip into sharp.
The strawberry arrives twice, as liqueur and as puree, so the flavour reads as berries rather than candy as long as the puree is real fruit.
Blending for a thick, smooth drink
Use crushed ice for a smoother result, and blend only briefly so the ice does not melt into water. Hulled fresh strawberries blended until completely smooth work for the puree. Frozen berries, thawed first, are fine too and often give a thicker drink.
If seeds bother you, push the puree through a sieve before it goes in the blender. Shake the tin of coconut cream before opening, because the fat floats to the top.
Swaps, a lighter pour and a version without alcohol
If you have no strawberry liqueur, use a little more puree with a touch of sugar syrup. Coconut rum doubles down on the coconut, and a squeeze of lime cuts the sweetness if it feels heavy.
For an alcohol-free drink, leave out the rum and liqueur and add extra apple juice and puree, then blend with ice. For a party, blend in batches, since a crowded blender will not crush the ice properly.
Questions
Can I use frozen strawberries?
Yes. Thaw them a little first so they blend smoothly, and use a little less ice, since the berries already chill the drink. Frozen fruit often gives a thicker, colder result than fresh.
Why is my Strawberry Colada watery?
Too much ice or too long in the blender melts it into thin slush. Blend briefly with crushed ice, and add more frozen fruit rather than more ice if it looks thin.
Can I make it without a blender?
Shake everything hard with ice and strain it over fresh crushed ice. Mash the strawberry puree smooth first. It will be thinner and less creamy than the blended drink, but the flavours still work.
