What the Italian Dream tastes like
Irish cream supplies the base, with cream, vanilla and a little chocolate and whiskey warmth. The amaretto adds a marzipan like almond flavour that makes it feel a touch more grown up than a plain Irish cream shake. Fresh cream makes it thicker and smoother, and the crushed ice turns it frosty.
This is a drink for after dinner, and it is sweet and heavy enough that one is often plenty. It suits people who enjoy dessert drinks and almond flavours, and it will not appeal to anyone who wants something dry, bitter or sharp.
How to blend an Italian Dream that is smooth, not icy
Pour the Irish cream, amaretto and cream into the blender first, then add the crushed ice so the blades work through liquid before they meet ice. Blend until it looks like a thick milkshake with no flecks of ice, which usually takes a few seconds longer than you expect. If it is too thin, add a little more ice and blend again.
Pour straight away into a chilled parfait glass, because the drink starts to melt and separate as it stands. Chilling the glass in the freezer for a few minutes first keeps the texture thick for longer. A grating of nutmeg or a dusting of cocoa on top is a nice finish, but it is not needed.
Italian Dream swaps and make-ahead tips
If you do not have amaretto, a drop of almond essence in the Irish cream gives a similar almond note without the extra liqueur, though the flavour is flatter. A hazelnut liqueur gives a nuttier, chocolate style version. Pouring cream or half and half both work in place of heavy cream, but richer cream gives a thicker drink.
For a lighter version, use milk in place of the cream and a little less ice. For an alcohol free version, use a chocolate or coffee flavoured milk with almond syrup, blended with ice. For a party, blend in small batches and keep the glasses in the freezer, since a large batch melts before it is served.
Questions
What does an Italian Dream taste like?
It tastes like a creamy almond milkshake with a hint of coffee and vanilla. The Irish cream gives the base, the amaretto adds almond, and the crushed ice makes it thick and frosty.
Will the cream curdle in an Italian Dream?
Unlikely. There is no citrus or other acid in the recipe, so the cream stays smooth. Use fresh cream and drink it soon after blending, because it can separate as it melts.
Can I make an Italian Dream without a blender?
You can shake the ingredients hard with ice and strain into the glass over fresh crushed ice. It will be thinner than the blended version but still creamy and nutty.
