Where the Rum Runner comes from, and how this one tastes
The drink is often credited to a tiki bar in Islamorada in the Florida Keys, and its name is usually tied to the story of rum smugglers in the Prohibition years. Accounts differ on the details, so treat the history as a good bar story rather than settled fact.
Many versions add orange and pineapple juice. This one does not, so the lime is sharper and the banana and blackberry are more upfront. If you want a softer, more punch-like drink, a splash of pineapple or orange juice in the blender does that without spoiling the balance.
Getting the slush right instead of a watery mess
The usual complaint with frozen rum drinks is that they turn into thin, icy water or a lump the blender cannot move. Put the liquids in the blender first, then add the crushed ice, and blend until the surface stops looking gritty. If the blades stall, add a little more rum or juice, not water.
Chill the glass in the freezer beforehand and blend only when you are ready to pour, because crushed ice melts fast and the drink loses its thick texture within minutes.
Swaps, lighter versions and making a jug for friends
A light rum keeps the fruit clear, while a dark rum adds a molasses depth that goes well with the banana. Blackberry liqueur or crème de mûre can stand in for blackberry brandy and will taste a little fresher and less boozy. If you have no banana liqueur, a ripe banana in the blender gives a natural version, though it is thicker and a little less sweet.
For a lower alcohol version, use less rum and add pineapple juice. For a party, mix everything except the ice in a jug, keep it cold, and blend it in batches so each round stays thick.
Questions
Should the Florida Rum Runner be frozen or served on the rocks?
This recipe is blended with crushed ice into a slush. You can also shake it with ice and strain over fresh ice for a drink that is less sweet in the mouth and easier to make without a blender.
What is blackberry brandy and can I swap it?
Blackberry brandy is a sweet fruit liqueur made from blackberries. A blackberry liqueur is the closest swap, and it usually tastes fresher. A raspberry liqueur also works, although the flavour moves towards raspberry rather than dark berry.
Why does my Rum Runner taste too sweet?
Banana liqueur, blackberry brandy and grenadine are all sweet, so lime is doing the balancing. Add a little more lime juice, or reduce the grenadine, and make sure the drink is properly cold, because warm slush always tastes sweeter.
