What five spirits and orange juice taste like together
Rum, gin, vodka, tequila and triple sec each pull in a different direction, so the juice and sour mix have a lot of work to do. What you taste first is orange and lemon, with the triple sec rounding it into something close to a spiked orange cordial. The gin and tequila show up afterwards as a faint herbal, grassy edge, while the vodka and rum mostly add weight.
It is sweet and sharp rather than complex, and it is far stronger than it drinks. That is the whole trap. If you like a long, fruity drink and do not mind one that sneaks up on you, it makes a fun party piece. If you want to pick out each spirit, it will disappoint, because they blur together.
Shaking it so it tastes fresh, not flat
Build the drink in a shaker with plenty of ice rather than in the serving glass. Shake hard until the outside of the shaker is frosty, then strain over fresh ice in a highball glass. Ice that has already been shaken is half melted, so pouring over new ice keeps the drink cold for longer and stops it turning watery.
Sour mix is the ingredient most likely to taste artificial. A mix made from fresh lemon juice and sugar syrup gives a cleaner finish and takes the edge off the sweetness. If you are using a bottled mix, taste it on its own first so you know how sweet the finished drink will be.
Swaps, a lighter version and a jug for a crowd
The five spirits are the point of the name, so swapping one out makes it a different drink, but it will still taste good. For a lighter version, keep the orange liqueur and juice, use only the rum and vodka, and top with a splash of soda water. For an alcohol-free take, mix orange juice, a squeeze of lemon, a little sugar syrup and soda water over ice.
For a party, stir the five spirits together in a jug ahead of time and keep it in the fridge. Add the juice and sour mix just before serving, stir with plenty of ice for a minute, and pour into glasses of fresh ice.
Pacing a drink with five spirits in it
One of these is a generous serve, so most people will be happy with a single glass. Eat something first, keep water nearby, and do not let the orange juice fool you into drinking it like a soft drink.
Questions
Can I make Five in the Morning without sour mix?
Yes. Use fresh lemon juice with a little sugar syrup instead. It will taste brighter and less sweet than a bottled mix. Shake as usual, taste it, and stir in more sugar syrup a little at a time if it comes out too sharp.
Does it taste as strong as it is?
No, it tastes milder than it is, because the orange juice and sour mix cover the spirits. That is why people finish one quickly. Sip it slowly, have water alongside, and do not judge the strength by the flavour.
What glass should I use?
A tall highball glass over fresh ice, since this is a long drink with a lot of juice in it. A short glass will overflow, and a wine glass loses its chill quickly.
