- Coconut Cream Pie Rate this Recipe Prep Time 3 minutes minutesTotal Time 3 minutes minutes Ingredients - What's in it?▢ 1 oz Vanilla Schnapps▢ 1 oz Coconut Rum▢ 3 oz Cream Adjust Servings 1 serving Instructions - How to make it:Combine all ingredients into a shaker with ice shake and strain into cocktail glass. Espresso Martini Fruit Tingle Cocktail Course Cocktail Captain With A Skirt Pineapple Bomb