Ingredients
- 1 Cup(s) Spiced Rum
- 1 Cup(s) Water
- 1 Packet(s) Cherry Jello
Instructions
Boil the Water:
- In a saucepan, bring 1 cup of water to a boil.
Mix in the Jello:
- Add the cherry jello packet to the boiling water and stir for 2 minutes until fully dissolved.
Add the Spiced Rum:
- Pour in 1 cup of spiced rum and stir until well mixed.
Pour and Refrigerate:
- Pour the mixture into a pan or small cups, then refrigerate until fully set.
Serve:
- Once set, cut into squares or serve in individual cups and enjoy!
Notes
Estimated Nutrition:
Where it came from
Jello shots aren't exactly found in dusty, old cocktail tomes. Their origin is a bit hazy, but they've been a staple of casual parties and college dorms for decades. No one's quite sure who put the first boozy gelatin together, but it was likely a home bartender looking for a fun way to get the party started.
These are less a 'cocktail' in the traditional sense and more a boozy dessert or a playful shot. They sit in their own category, a distant cousin to a mixed drink. The Spiced Cherry version sets itself apart from the basic vodka-and-jello by bringing in a warm, complex note that makes it feel a little more intentional.
You won't be ordering these at a swanky lounge, and your bartender probably isn't prepping them for a Saturday night rush. These are strictly for house parties, casual get-togethers, or when you're hosting and want to serve something that gets people talking and laughing. They are a guaranteed conversation starter.
What it tastes like
Expect a big hit of sweet, artificial cherry flavor upfront, exactly like the jello you remember from childhood. The spiced rum then kicks in, adding a layer of warmth and a hint of vanilla, cinnamon, and sometimes nutmeg. It smooths out the sweetness a bit, making it taste like a boozy cherry candy. The texture is key here, a wobbly, quick delivery system for the flavor.
These aren't weak. With roughly one part spiced rum to one part water (before the jello mix), your final product is going to land somewhere around 20% ABV. That's significantly stronger than most beers, which clock in around 4-9%. Treat these like a proper shot. They go down easy, so don't underestimate them.
The technique
Building these is straightforward. Boil your water, whisk in the jello until every last granule is gone, then take it off the heat before you add the rum. Pour it into your chosen vessels, whether that's a baking dish for cutting or individual shot cups. Then it's just a waiting game in the fridge.
The one technique tip that matters most is patience. Don't rush the chill. Give these things a solid four hours, or ideally, let them set overnight. A properly firm jello shot is a happy jello shot. Nobody wants a sad, half-liquid mess when they reach for a party starter.
Ingredient Spotlight
The bottles that make or break this drink.
Spiced Rum
- Use
- A good quality dark spiced rum. Kraken, Sailor Jerry, or Captain Morgan all work well here, bringing distinct notes of vanilla, cinnamon, and other baking spices.
- Skip
- Unspiced white rum will make it taste like a basic frat party jello shot. Gold rum without added spices will lack the warmth that makes this version special.
- Why
- The spiced rum is the 'spiced' in Spiced Cherry Jello Shots. It adds depth, warmth, and a layer of complexity beyond just sweet fruit and alcohol.
Cherry Jello
- Use
- Any standard packet of cherry flavored gelatin mix. The artificial cherry flavor is part of the charm here, so don't overthink it.
- Skip
- Sugar-free versions can sometimes affect the set and texture. Other fruit flavors are fine if you want a different drink, but they won't be 'Spiced Cherry'.
- Why
- This is the base flavor and the iconic red color. Without it, you just have boozy gelatin. The cherry and spice are a classic pairing.
Three Variations
Three real ways bartenders riff on this drink.
Tropical Twist
- Swap spiced rum for coconut rum
- For a vacation vibe, use a good coconut rum instead of spiced rum. It brings a lighter, sweeter, and more beachy feel to the cherry base.
Fireball Cherry
- Bring the heat with cinnamon whiskey
- Replace the spiced rum with Fireball Cinnamon Whisky. You'll get an intense cinnamon kick that pairs surprisingly well with the sweet cherry.
Sour Cherry Bomb
- Add a tart edge with citrus
- After the jello is dissolved and off the heat, stir in about 1/4 cup of fresh lime or lemon juice along with the rum. It cuts through the sweetness with a pleasant tang.
What if I don't have…
Quick substitutions for when the bottle shop is closed.
Use dark rum and add a dash of cinnamon and vanilla extract to the mixture. Or, if you're not picky about the 'spiced' part, vodka works for a generic jello shot.
Strawberry or raspberry jello are easy, common swaps that still pair well with spiced rum or other dark spirits.
Pour the mixture into a standard 9×13 inch baking pan. Once set, you can cut it into squares or rectangles for serving. Just make sure to grease the pan lightly or line with parchment for easy removal.
You can microwave the water in a microwave-safe bowl until boiling. Then proceed with adding the jello and rum as instructed. Stir well to ensure dissolution.
Frequently Asked Questions
Direct answers to what people search for after Googling this drink.
What is in a Spiced Cherry Jello Shots?
Spiced Cherry Jello Shots contain spiced rum, water, and a packet of cherry flavored gelatin mix.
How strong are Spiced Cherry Jello Shots?
They typically clock in around 20% ABV, making them stronger than most beers. Treat them like a shot and pace yourself.
Can I use different flavored jello?
Absolutely. Strawberry, raspberry, or even lime jello can be used for different flavor profiles. Just keep the rum pairing in mind.
Can I make these ahead of time?
Yes, jello shots require several hours to set, so making them a day in advance is ideal. They will keep in the fridge for a few days.
Why can't I boil the rum?
Alcohol evaporates at a lower temperature than water. Adding rum to boiling water will cause a significant amount of the alcohol to cook off, reducing the strength of your shots.
How long do Spiced Cherry Jello Shots take to set?
They need a minimum of 2-4 hours in the refrigerator to set, but for the best firm texture, let them chill overnight.
What's the best way to serve jello shots?
Individual plastic shot cups with lids are convenient for parties. Alternatively, pour the mixture into a pan, let it set, then cut into squares or shapes for serving.
Are these considered a cocktail?
While they contain alcohol, jello shots are generally considered more of a party novelty or a boozy dessert than a traditional mixed cocktail you'd order at a bar.
More Like This
More drinks in the same family.
