Ingredients
- 1/4 oz Coconut Rum
- .5 oz Almond Liqueur
- .5 oz Coffee Liqueur
- 1 oz Butterscotch Schnapps
- 1 Splash Milk
Instructions
Combine Ingredients:
- In a beer mug, combine 0.25 oz coconut rum, 0.5 oz almond liqueur, 0.5 oz coffee liqueur, 1 oz butterscotch schnapps, and a splash of milk.
Stir:
- Stir the mixture well to combine all the flavors.
Serve:
- Serve immediately and enjoy the sweet, creamy flavors of the Butter Baby!
Notes
Estimated Nutrition:
Where it came from
No clean attribution for the Butter Baby. It's the kind of sweet, multi-liqueur concoction that likely popped up in bars during the late 20th century, a time when layered shots and dessert drinks were having a moment.
This drink falls squarely into the "dessert cocktail" or "sweet sipper" category. Think of it as a grown-up milkshake without the ice cream, a close relative to the Mudslide or a creamy shooter, but with a distinct butterscotch and coconut twist.
You'll find this most at home in a casual bar, a house party, or as a post-dinner treat when you've already committed to indulging. It's not a pre-dinner aperitif, unless you're really going for it.
What it tastes like
The first sip is all about that creamy, rich butterscotch, quickly followed by the nutty warmth of almond and a subtle hint of coconut. The coffee liqueur grounds the sweetness with a touch of bitterness, keeping it from becoming pure sugar shock. The milk ties it all together into a smooth, decadent package.
With about 2.25 ounces of boozy goodness, this drink lands around 19-20% ABV. That puts it in the range of a strong fortified wine, or roughly three times the alcohol content of your average light beer. It drinks easy, but it's got more punch than a standard pint.
The technique
Building a Butter Baby is straightforward. Grab a beer mug, or whatever sturdy glass you have on hand. Pour in the coconut rum, almond liqueur, coffee liqueur, and butterscotch schnapps. Finish with a splash of milk.
The key here is stirring. You're not shaking; you're marrying a few different liqueurs with different densities. Give it a proper stir until everything is fully integrated and the mixture looks consistently creamy. Nobody wants a layer of pure schnapps at the bottom.
Ingredient Spotlight
The bottles that make or break this drink.
Butterscotch Schnapps
- Use
- Dekuyper, Bols, or any reputable schnapps brand.
- Skip
- Caramel syrup. It's not the same depth of flavor.
- Why
- It's the star of the show. The namesake, the sweetness, the defining flavor. Don't skimp.
Coffee Liqueur
- Use
- Kahlua, Tia Maria, or a similar quality coffee liqueur.
- Skip
- Espresso shot. It'll be too bitter without the sugar.
- Why
- It provides a necessary counterpoint to the immense sweetness of the other ingredients, adding a layer of roasted depth and a hint of balance.
Three Variations
Three real ways bartenders riff on this drink.
Butter Baby Shot
- All the flavor, quicker delivery.
- Scale down the ingredients to fit a shot glass. It's a sweet, creamy shooter for when you need a fast hit of dessert.
Frozen Butter Baby
- A boozy milkshake for hot days.
- Combine all ingredients with a scoop of ice and blend until smooth. Serve with a straw and maybe a whipped cream topping.
Spiked Butter Baby
- For when you need an extra kick.
- Add 0.5 oz of neutral vodka to the original recipe. It bumps up the alcohol without messing with the flavor profile too much.
What if I don't have…
Quick substitutions for when the bottle shop is closed.
Use a light rum and a tiny dash of coconut extract or syrup.
Amaretto is the standard. If you're out, a hazelnut liqueur can work for a different nutty vibe.
A strong, sweetened cold brew coffee concentrate could stand in, but adjust for sweetness.
Any sturdy tumbler or even a large rocks glass will do the job.
Frequently Asked Questions
Direct answers to what people search for after Googling this drink.
What is in a Butter Baby?
It's made with coconut rum, almond liqueur, coffee liqueur, butterscotch schnapps, and a splash of milk.
Is the Butter Baby a shot or a cocktail?
It's usually served as a small sipper or a dessert cocktail, though you could easily scale it down into a sweet shot.
How sweet is the Butter Baby?
It's definitely on the sweeter side. Expect a creamy, candy-like flavor profile, balanced slightly by the coffee liqueur.
What kind of milk should I use for a Butter Baby?
Whole milk or half-and-half will give you the richest, creamiest texture. Skim milk works, but it won't be as decadent.
Can you make a dairy-free Butter Baby?
Absolutely. Swap the milk for a splash of oat milk or almond milk. Coconut milk could also work, leaning into the coconut rum flavor.
What does a Butter Baby taste like?
Imagine a boozy butterscotch candy with hints of almond, coconut, and a subtle coffee finish. It's rich, sweet, and creamy.
Is the Butter Baby a strong drink?
While it tastes sweet and smooth, it's roughly 19-20% ABV, making it stronger than most beers and on par with a glass of fortified wine. Sip it.
When is the best time to drink a Butter Baby?
This is a dessert drink through and through. It's ideal for after dinner, as a sweet treat, or for a casual party where sweet, easy-drinking cocktails are appreciated.
More Like This
More drinks in the same family.
