What it tastes like, and where the mint comes from
The recipe lists only coconut rum, ice and ice cream, so any mint comes from the ice cream you choose or from a garnish. Mint chocolate chip turns the drink into something close to an after-dinner mint, with cool menthol notes against the coconut. Vanilla gives a softer shake in the style of a piƱa colada, and a fresh mint sprig on top adds aroma without changing the taste much.
It is very rich and quite sweet, because the ice cream carries most of the volume and most of the sugar. People who love thick, creamy drinks will enjoy it, while anyone who prefers something crisp would be happier with a citrus cocktail. The cream also hides the rum, so it disappears faster than its strength suggests.
Blending it thick instead of watery
Use ice cream straight from the freezer rather than softened, and put the rum into the blender first so the blades catch the liquid before they hit the ice cream. Blend until the mixture is smooth and thick, then stop. Blending for too long warms it up and turns it into a thin soup. If it looks too stiff to pour, add a small splash of milk or rum and pulse once.
Put the serving glass in the freezer for a few minutes beforehand, because a cold glass buys you time before the drink starts melting. A tall glass suits it best, with a wide straw or a long spoon. Pour it straight away, as the texture is at its best for the first few minutes.
Swaps and ways to change it
Coconut ice cream or a scoop of coconut sorbet gives a dairy-free version with a sharper tropical taste. If you want more coconut flavour without more alcohol, replace some of the rum with chilled coconut cream. Spiced rum works in place of the coconut rum and adds vanilla and warm spice.
For an alcohol-free version, blend the ice cream with ice and chilled coconut milk, then finish with a little coconut syrup if you want it sweeter. At a party, blend in small batches rather than one large one, since a crowded blender leaves lumps and the mixture melts while you wait.
Questions
What ice cream goes in a Mint Vacation Treat?
Mint chocolate chip matches the name and gives a cool, minty shake. Vanilla is the easy option and tastes more like a coconut milkshake. Pick a good-quality, creamy ice cream, since it makes up most of the drink.
Can I make it without a blender?
You can get close. Let the ice cream soften a little, beat it with the rum in a big bowl or jar until smooth, and serve it over crushed ice. It will be thinner than the blended version but still tastes right.
Can I make the Mint Vacation Treat ahead of time?
Not really, because it melts and separates quickly. You can measure the rum and set out the ice cream and glasses in advance, then blend each round fresh just before serving.
