- Bleacher Creature Rate this Recipe Prep Time 3 minutesTotal Time 3 minutes Ingredients - What's in it?▢ 1.5 oz Butterscotch Schnapps▢ 1.5 oz OP Rum Adjust Servings 1 serving Instructions - How to make it:Pour butterscotch over rum. Do not stir. Pina Colada DARK ’N’ STORMY Course Shot Bleeding Bacardi Black Forest Cake