- Alien Nipple Rate this Recipe Prep Time 3 minutesTotal Time 3 minutes Ingredients - What's in it?▢ .5 oz Butterscotch Schnapps▢ .25 oz Irish Cream▢ .25 oz Melon Liqueur Adjust Servings 1 serving Instructions - How to make it:Add Butterscotch first. layer Irish cream on top. and pour in melon liqueur. Whiskey Sour Cocktail Toblerone Cocktail Recipe Course Shot Almond Joy 2 Alabama Slammer 3