What the cornstarch does to this hot chocolate
Cornstarch is the whole trick here. Once it heats in the milk, the starch swells and holds the liquid, which is why this version coats a spoon and stays hot for longer than a regular cup.
The flavour is cocoa first and sugar second, with the milk keeping it round rather than bitter. Because there is no melted chocolate bar in it, it tastes cleaner and more cocoa-forward than a ganache-style hot chocolate. It is on the sweeter side, so people who like dark chocolate may enjoy it most with a good-quality unsweetened cocoa.
How to get it smooth, with no lumps or skin
Lumps come from adding the milk too fast, or from cocoa that was never sifted. Sift the cocoa and sugar together first, dissolve the cornstarch fully in cold water, and stir that into the dry mix to make a paste before any milk goes in. Then add the milk a little at a time while whisking, so each splash loosens the paste before the next one arrives.
Keep the heat at medium and keep whisking, because cornstarch sets quickly once the pot nears a simmer and then catches on the base of the pan. It is ready when it coats the back of a spoon and a finger drawn through leaves a clean line. A skin forms as it cools, so pour it straight away, or press a piece of baking paper onto the surface if it has to wait.
Spice, dairy-free swaps and a grown-up version
A pinch of cinnamon, a drop of vanilla or a very small pinch of chilli powder all suit the cocoa. Oat or soy milk thickens in the same way as dairy, while almond milk gives a thinner result.
For a grown-up version, take the pot off the heat and stir in a splash of dark rum or brandy at the end, so the alcohol flavour stays sharp. Leftovers set like a pudding in the fridge and loosen again when reheated gently with a splash of extra milk.
Questions
Why did my hot chocolate go lumpy?
Lumps usually come from adding the milk too quickly or skipping the sifting. Make a smooth paste from the cocoa, sugar and dissolved cornstarch first, then whisk the milk in gradually. If lumps still form, pour the drink through a sieve.
Can I make it ahead and reheat it?
Yes. It keeps in the fridge for a couple of days and sets firm as it chills. Reheat slowly over low heat with a splash of extra milk, whisking the whole time, until it loosens back to a pouring thickness.
Can I use dairy-free milk?
Oat and soy milk work well and thicken like dairy milk. Almond milk is thinner, so the result is less rich. Whichever you use, whisk constantly and keep the heat at medium so the cornstarch cooks evenly.
