- Butterscotch Cookie Shot Rate this Recipe Prep Time 3 minutesTotal Time 3 minutes Ingredients - What's in it?▢ .5 oz Irish Cream▢ .5 oz Butterscotch Schnapps Adjust Servings 1 serving Instructions - How to make it:Layer into shot glass and enjoy! Dry Negroni Cocktail Jolly Rancher Course Shot Girl Scout Cookie Klingon Battlejuice